Should all prayers be improvisational?  What is the role (and relevance) of classical prayers, written and recited, in the lives of Christians today?

About ten years ago, a friend gave me a copy of the Book of Common Prayer1, and I immediately fell in love with it!  I was leading worship for a youth group at the time, and I started pulling in prayers from the Book of Common Prayer for the group to recite together …and for myself or another youth leader to pray over the group …and for us to do in a more call-and-response type fashion.  (and many more uses!)

Christian-Prayer bookThe Book of Common Prayer is the Protestant version of the Catholics‘ Liturgy of the Hours2.  These books are literally day-by-day prayer guides for individuals and congregations that organize the prayers of the Body of Christ, five times each day, 365 days each year.  They follow the liturgical calendar, and even organize the reading of the entire Bible into a three-year cycle.

When Christians follow these books, they do so with other believers around the world praying that same day’s prayers – reading that same day’s assigned Scriptures.  They also join the millions of Christians who went before and who prayed those same prayers and read those same Scriptures on those same days in the past!

In his book on the value of the classical forms of prayer and worship, Mark Galli wrote,

After praying the liturgy for a few years, it becomes impossible to pray alone, or feel alone when we pray by ourselves. In liturgy, we know instinctively that we are part of something bigger than ourselves.3

Here, Galli is referring to the Body of Christ, all praying the same guided prayers out of the same book on the same day.  Even if you involve these classical prayers in your time alone with God, you are not isolated from the larger Body of Christ, which is at that moment lifting up the same prayers to God along with you!

I suppose on a contemporary scale, this would be like all the people who read today’s entry in My Upmost for His Highest4 or Jesus Calling5.  Even though each person may have read it separately, their spirits were joined together with the spirits of all the others around the world who read, thought about, and prayed about that same entry today.

I was discussing the power of written and recited prayers recently with a group of friends, and one of them remarked,

There have been times where, as a church or as a small group, we were all joining together for a daily reading from the same book. As such, you knew that you were having a shared experience with other brothers and sisters in Christ. In these instances, the only way to feel alone is to be the person who didn’t join in.

bible-prayinghandsFor those times when we react against the concept of written prayers (I certainly have before, myself!) – thinking that in order for our prayers to be ‘real’ and to ‘come from the heart’, they must be improvisational – it is important to remember that the Bible is riddled with written prayers that we recite all the time!  From Moses’ prayer of praise in Exodus, to the prayers of David in 1-2 Samuel, to the many recorded and oft-recited prayers in the Psalms, all the way to the prayers of Jesus and His disciples recorded throughout the New Testament.

Besides this, just because we use someone else’s words when we pray, that doesn’t mean our praying of their words doesn’t come from our hearts, too:

  • Have you ever bought a greeting card for someone because you thought, “now this is exactly what I wanted to say, only I couldn’t compose the words myself!”
  • Have you ever shared a song with someone, because the lyrics articulated your feelings even better than your own words could have?

The same applies to the classical prayers that Christians have been praying for millennia.  Sometimes I find that what they prayed is exactly what I wanted to pray… only I couldn’t pinpoint the right words.  They said it even better than I could!  And now I get to share my heart with God, borrowing on their words, and sharing them with millions around the world offering the same words to God at the same time!

I greatly value our ability to get to join in with the prayers that the Church has been lifting up to heaven for centuries – to get to share in the wealth of spiritual history and investments made by generations of faithful believers before me.  We stand on their shoulders as we recite their prayers, from our hearts, to God.


1 The Book of Common Prayer (Oxford University Press, 2007). 1 The Book of Common Prayer (Oxford University Press, 2007).

2 Liturgy of the Hours (Catholic Book Publishing Co, 1986).

3 Mark Galli, Beyond Smells and Bells: The Wonder and Power of Christian Liturgy (Paraclete, 2008), 37.

4 Oswald Chambers, My Upmost for His Highest (Barbour Publishing, Inc., 1963).

5 Sarah Young, Jesus Calling: Enjoying Peace in His Presence (Thomas Nelson, 2004).